Apr 24 2008

Voice in stories

Published by dwsmith at 8:49 pm under On Writing

It has been an interesting month or so.  I’ve been working on a novel that is under a fairly tight deadline, and have a request from another editor for a novel that I have a pretty rough draft finished on, but needs a second pass to bring up voice.

And both of these books are complete voice novels.

For the writer who wrote the two original Men in Black novels back ten years ago, who wrote an entire Dixon Hill Trek novel, I thought it would not be a problem.  That will teach me to assume anything.

For a large part of the last five years, I’ve worked on taking voice out of my writing, making my prose invisible to the reader.  This came from working on James Patterson-like thrillers book after book and a ton of young adult books without voice.

So suddenly, I’m having to stuff voice back into my work, and wow has this been interesting, to say the least.  And, to be honest, it felt sort of freeing as well.  At least right up to the point where I handed Kris three chapters on the rewrite novel and she beat on it with a red pen and said the voice wasn’t there.

I had thought it was there.  But when a Hugo Award winning editor says it isn’t there, you sort of slink back to your office, sit in your chair staring at the screen, and wonder just what the hell voice is exactly.

Of course, that’s the writer doing that thinking.  As an editor and a teacher, I know what voice is, can even tell another writer how to bring up voice in a story.  But me, the writer, just sat there sort of disgusted with myself.  How, in a short five years, had I managed to take all my voice out of my novels so successfully?

So, I went back to basics.  I looked at other writers using strong voices, studied what they did.  Then I went back to focusing on the character and the details the character would see, and the ATTITUDE of the character while looking at every detail.  And I climbed inside that character’s head, planted myself firmly there, and wrote a new couple of first pages.

This time Kris read them, laughed (thank God) and handed them back to me.  “Got it.”

I went back to my trusty writing office, sat down at the computer and stared at the screen and asked myself “Got what?”  And “How did I just do that?”

I have written over ninety novels, been at this business full time for over twenty years, and it never gets boring.  From day one to now it has been just as fun, just as frightening, and just as full of unknowns every time I sit in front of a blank page.

So now I go back upstairs to work, pushing voice back to the surface of my writing every sentence, and with luck, making the voice strong enough to sell.

Cheers,  Dean

3 Responses to “Voice in stories”

  1. Jim Johnsonon 28 Apr 2008 at 5:45 am

    So I guess that would bring up the obvious question…what does voice mean to you? As either a writer or editor, or heck, maybe both.

  2. Deborahon 29 Apr 2008 at 8:02 am

    Besides Jim’s question, I’d also be interested in hearing more about why you wanted to make your writing “transparent”. Yes, I know you cited Patterson (who sells extremely well) :D but JMNSHO, I prefer novels that leave *in* a very strong voice. I think that makes them distinct and sets them apart from the rest. On that note, since you call Patterson a very transparent writer, who would you say has some of the strongest voices at the moment?

  3. dwsmithon 30 Apr 2008 at 9:22 pm

    I hope I answered your questions in my next entry. If not, ask again.

    However, Deborah, why did I want my voice out of a novel or novels? Easy, it is the form. Thrillers are plot driven books completely, and the best thriller writers have invisible voices.

    The best writer working is Stephen King and his voice is his story and character and nothing more, although he lately lets his own voice out a tiny bit. But his focus is story and character and his “writer voice” is often so far in the back that it can’t be seen unless he reads it aloud to you. Then you can hear it, interestingly enough.

    So, I’m now able to write both. Character voice grabs readers if the story is suited to a strong voice. But the top sellers in the business have little or no author voice. James Patterson, Nora Roberts, Stephen King, and so on. You have to go a ways down the list to find a strong author voice writer. Just a thought.

    Cheers
    Dean

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

Leave a Reply